Would You Rather?

I have looked through the games and couldn't find this game! (apologies if I'm as blind as a bat). It's really quite simple but it can be so fun at the same time. Basically someone answers would you rather question for the character they reply as and then ask another question for the person who is replying next? 


Eg. 
Previous Poster: would you rather be caught trespassing in the Ministry or be ambushed by a pair of mountain trolls? 

Alexander: Pair of mountain trolls because Alexander wants to climb his way to the top in the Ministry and getting caught trespassing in the ministry could hinder his climb. 


---- 
We can be super creative and think all sorts of scenarios, plus if you want to include a what would you do aspect you could say what your character would do. Plus this may inspire some threads with people! They can be good, bad, naughty, painful, humiliating, exhilarating. 

I guess we'll start with the example question: 

would you rather be caught trespassing in the Ministry or be ambushed by a pair of mountain trolls?

Trespassing in the Ministry, because Elliot is a muggle so the worst that could happen is they'd modify his memory.


Would you rather be a muggle-born with magic hating parents or a squib with blood prejudiced parents?

This is Pansy's worst nightmare. She wouldn't want to not be able to produce magic, especially I find her rest of her family can so that's rules Squib out. But then she wouldn't want to be muggle born because it goes against her pure blood values. So I'd say squib with really prejudice parents as that would actually be the scenario if she were squib born and she would still be able to get involved in the magical community and write for the daily prophet and continue to say she was part of the pure Blood Parkinson legacy. 

Would your character rather be sentenced to Azkaban for 8 years or have their wand taken from them but they're free to continue life as normal just they aren't allowed to have another wand again?

Selwyn can barely handle normal life, so I doubt he'd do very well in Azkaban. Whereas he'd probably be fine without a wand. He's very adaptable.

Would you rather have a long but boring life or a short exciting one?

Short exciting one because you'll always wonder in the end why you never did something daring. Where's if you lived a short exciting life at least you know you did something that made you happy. Just like they always say you have one life to live make the most of it.

Would your character rather when traveling the world be go with the flow or plan everything out down to the last second?

Go with the flow for sure. She would like to know where the journey starts but where it ends is a mystery and the beauty of adventure.


Would you rather fail all of your NEWT's and not be allowed to resit your exams ever or do exceptionally well in your NEWT's but everyone think you've cheated and so are discredited for your achievements?

The latter, for sure. At least there is a chance at redemption there. With the former, you couldn't even get a job and hope to prove yourself, y'know?

Would you rather... be forced to travel everywhere by hippogriff (with the exception of, if you're in the Muggle world, having to walk everywhere)
or
have to brush Fluffy's teeth once a month?

Brush fluffy's teeth once a month ... Just as long as there is a lullaby playing in the background.


Would you rather... Be blackmailed into attacking the Head of Hogwarts (baring in mind there will be severe consequences for you).

Or.

Blackmailed into spreading a rumor about someone for a month and continuously providing fake evidence to support the rumor (baring in mind there wont be any consequences for you you'll just ruins someones life a little).


Or.

Refused to be blackmailed and have your family murdered.

God...I sound like a horrible person,  but as long as I apologize and explain why I did it, they'll understand hopefully!

Blackmailed into spreading a rumor about someone for a month and continuously providing fake evidence to support the rumor


After  being tortured like Longbottoms's(Neville's parents)were,  would you rather die because of it or be like Neville's parents were in the book?

Die because of it. I think it'd be harder for the family to see you in the way Neville had to see his parents. 


Would you rather:
Be placed under the imperius curse and have no control over your actions for a month or suffer the cruciatus curse for half an hour once a week for a month.